
Key Points
- 01UnitedHealth sues over 2027 Medicare Advantage star ratings
- 02Lawsuit contests CMS use of 26 measures for 45 contracts
- 03UnitedHealth says proper calculation would add 0.5–1.5 stars
- 04UnitedHealth is at least the 15th Medicare Advantage plan to challenge 2027 ratings
UnitedHealth launches legal challenge to 2027 star ratings
UnitedHealth Group has sued the US government over its 2027 Medicare Advantage star ratings, alleging that the lowered scores threaten imminent harm by depriving the insurer of bonus payments and reducing benefits for patients. The complaint, filed late on Thursday in federal court in Brunswick, Georgia, targets how the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services calculated quality ratings for the company’s Medicare Advantage plans.
UnitedHealth argues that CMS improperly used 26 measures to compute ratings for 45 contracts, claiming the agency lacked statutory authority, failed to provide a chance to object, or both. The company says that, if calculated correctly, the ratings for those 45 contracts would rise by at least 0.5 stars and as much as 1.5 stars.
In a statement on the lawsuit, the Eden Prairie, Minnesota-based insurer said it did not take the step lightly and emphasized a commitment to working with CMS to modernize the star program and develop a more durable approach to measuring quality. CMS, which is part of the Department of Health and Human Services, declined to comment.
What is at stake in Medicare Advantage star scores
Medicare Advantage, also known as Part C, allows eligible beneficiaries to enroll in private health plans called Medicare Advantage Organizations instead of traditional Medicare. Plans receive star ratings ranging from one for poor to five for excellent, reflecting factors such as health screenings and customer satisfaction.
Plans with at least four stars qualify for bonus payments from the government, which can reach hundreds of millions or even billions of dollars if costs remain low. Insurers argue that inconsistent measurement can push plans below this bonus threshold, affecting reimbursement and the competitive position of individual products.
UnitedHealth has said that improperly low ratings could reduce its ability to offer preventive care and may result in higher premiums for patients. The company describes the star ratings as the government’s principal signal to patients about plan quality.
Scale of UnitedHealth’s Medicare Advantage exposure
UnitedHealth is the largest Medicare Advantage insurer, serving about 7.61 million Medicare Advantage patients as of September 30. It holds roughly 30% of the Medicare Advantage market, ahead of competitors such as Humana and CVS.
Because of this scale, changes in star ratings can have significant implications for the company’s Medicare Advantage business economics and for a large base of beneficiaries. The dispute comes while the annual Medicare enrollment period, which ends on December 7, remains open, keeping the ratings and related benefits in focus for both insurers and enrollees.
Broader wave of litigation over 2027 ratings
UnitedHealth’s case forms part of a wider pushback by insurers against the 2027 Medicare Advantage star ratings. UnitedHealth is at least the 15th Medicare Advantage plan to sue CMS over how the 2027 ratings were calculated, with billions of dollars in potential payments at stake across the sector.
Other insurers, including Aetna parent CVS Health and Humana, have filed similar challenges to their own ratings. CVS has said it could lose more than $2 billion in bonus payments and rebate retention due to its ratings. UnitedHealth and CVS filed their lawsuits in the same federal court in Brunswick, Georgia.
Earlier this year, a federal judge in Brunswick ruled that CMS had calculated an incorrect star rating for Clover Health and ordered a recalculation. The same judge, US District Judge Lisa Godbey Wood, has been assigned to oversee the UnitedHealth and CVS cases, adding a precedent of prior recalculation to the backdrop of the new litigation.
Key Takeaways
- 01UnitedHealth’s lawsuit focuses on the technical methodology CMS used for 45 Medicare Advantage contracts, not on broader program participation.
- 02Financial exposure is tied to whether plans meet the four-star bonus threshold, making relatively small shifts in stars potentially significant.
- 03The dispute affects millions of Medicare Advantage beneficiaries at a time when they are actively choosing coverage for the upcoming year.
- 04With at least 15 plans now in court, the outcome of these cases could influence how Medicare Advantage quality is measured and funded in future years.
References
- https://www.investing.com/news/stock-market-news/unitedhealth-sues-us-government-over-lowered-medicare-advantage-star-ratings-5042270
- https://www.statnews.com/2026/11/20/unitedhealth-cms-medicare-advantage-lawsuit-star-rating/
- https://www.ad-hoc-news.de/boerse/news/corporate-news/unitedhealth-stock-faces-medicare-rating-lawsuit-stat-reports/70540106
- https://www.boursorama.com/bourse/actualites/unitedhealth-intente-un-proces-contre-le-gouvernement-americain-suite-a-la-baisse-des-notes-attribuees-au-programme-medicare-advantage-7b075f928be43c93641b06a88ae9a44d