
Key Points
- 01Apple will face trial in France in 2027 over alleged planned obsolescence of iPhones
- 02French prosecutors target Apple’s repair restrictions and “serialisation” practices
- 03If convicted, Apple risks fines up to €300,000 or a share of annual revenue plus potential client compensation
- 04Apple disputes the charges and says it strongly contests the allegations
Apple to stand trial in France over iPhone repair limits
Apple will stand trial in France in 2027 on suspicion of organising the planned obsolescence of several iPhone models by obstructing repair and refurbishment outside its authorised network. The proceedings follow a complaint filed in December 2022 by the association Halte à l’obsolescence programmée (HOP) and an investigation that led the Paris prosecutor’s office to bring the case before a criminal court.
Apple Distribution International and Apple Inc are scheduled to appear in Paris for a four‑day trial beginning June 17, 2027, after an initial court hearing on February 25, 2027. The company is charged with obstructing repair and refurbishment, in what campaigners describe as the first such case brought under France’s legal framework on planned obsolescence and repair rights.
Allegations focus on ‘serialisation’ and software locking
The case targets practices described as “serialisation”, where iPhone spare parts are digitally marked so that devices automatically recognise them when installed. If an iPhone does not detect an official component or a repair has not been validated by Apple, the device can block the part’s operation or restrict its functionality, even for original parts that are new or second‑hand.
A camera module replaced by an unauthorised repair shop risks disabling the Face ID feature; certain repairs risk loss of the “battery health” function. HOP argues that such measures have for several years affected frequently failing components such as screens, batteries and cameras, limiting the ability of independent repairers to offer services.
These practices are alleged to make repairs more expensive for consumers, with Apple stores currently charging more than €400 to replace the screen of a latest‑generation iPhone. HOP maintains that ending serialisation would reduce average repair costs and extend the usable life of devices, noting that around 200 kg of raw materials are needed to produce a single smartphone.
Potential penalties and regulatory backdrop
If found guilty, Apple could be fined up to €300,000 or a percentage of its annual revenue and may also face compensation claims from affected clients. Apple has responded that it strongly contests what it calls unfounded allegations.
The case is being pursued under French rules that prohibit techniques making it impossible or limiting the repair and reconditioning of products outside approved channels. It follows the entry into force in 2021 of France’s anti‑waste law for a circular economy, which targets practices such as serialisation that impede repair.
Since HOP’s initial complaint, the association notes that Apple announced in 2022 that it had limited serialisation practices on new iPhones and now allows third parties to have certain repairs validated. At the European level, a directive on the right to repair adopted in 2024 further tightens rules on manufacturers’ repair practices and aims to encourage longer product lifespans.
Prior disputes over iPhone performance and updates
This is not the first time Apple has faced legal action in France linked to the lifespan and performance of iPhones. In February 2021, the company agreed to pay €25 million for failing to inform users that some software updates could slow older devices.
That earlier settlement followed Apple’s admission in December 2017 that a version of its iOS software was reducing performance on older iPhones whose battery life was deteriorating. The new French case, centred on repair restrictions and serialisation, extends regulatory scrutiny from software‑related slowdowns to hardware and servicing policies for Apple’s flagship product.
Key Takeaways
- 01French prosecutors are using planned obsolescence and repair‑rights laws to challenge Apple’s control over iPhone servicing.
- 02The focus on serialisation shows regulators scrutinising how software and hardware design choices can constrain independent repair.
- 03Potential fines and compensation, while limited in headline amount, add legal and reputational risk around Apple’s core iPhone business.
References
- https://finance.yahoo.com/technology/articles/apple-faces-french-trial-over-074746257.html?.tsrc=rss
- https://www.thelocal.fr/20261117/apple-faces-paris-trial-over-alleged-planned-obsolescence-of-iphones
- https://www.lemonde.fr/pixels/article/2026/11/17/le-proces-d-apple-pour-obsolescence-programmee-s-ouvrira-en-juin-2027_6812904_4408996.html
- https://www.novethic.fr/economie-et-social/transformation-de-leconomie/apple-proces-obsolescence-programmee-entrave-reparabilite