
Key Points
EU launches legal action over border IT project
The European Union has initiated legal proceedings against IBM (IBM), Atos and Leonardo (LDOm) over delays in developing its Entry/Exit System, a new biometric border platform. The civil case was filed in Estonia in December 2025 by eu-LISA, the EU agency responsible for large-scale IT systems used in border management and security. Eu-LISA said that, following various delays in the delivery of the EES by a contracting consortium, the agency activated contractual and legal remedies to protect its financial interests.
The lawsuit targets a consortium of IBM Belgium, Atos Belgium and Leonardo, which was awarded a core contract for the system. The action was a response to repeated delays in delivering the central infrastructure for the EES during its development phase.
Contract scope and development dispute
In 2019, eu-LISA awarded the three companies a six-year core contract covering implementation and maintenance of the central Entry/Exit System. The contract’s value was increased to €212 million in 2021. The agency and the contractors had argued for several years over missed deadlines and the financial penalties linked to those delays.
In an October 2021 letter, Atos Belgium and IBM Belgium contested both the principle and the calculation of a fine imposed by eu-LISA, arguing that project delays stemmed from external factors, including the COVID-19 pandemic. In February 2022, IBM, Atos and Leonardo objected to revised deadlines and criticised the agency’s management, while eu-LISA maintained that the consortium remained responsible for the project until August of that year.
Operational issues and passenger impact
The Entry/Exit System electronically records the entry and exit of non-EU nationals at the bloc’s external borders and applies across 29 Schengen-area countries. It is designed to capture travellers’ fingerprints and facial images to identify visa overstayers, combat identity fraud and curb illegal migration. The system, initially scheduled to launch in 2022, became fully operational in April of this year.
The rollout has been troubled by technical and operational problems. Airports have reported malfunctioning EES kiosks and regular outages that led to waiting times of up to three hours at peak periods. Faulty fingerprint scanners also contributed to long queues at European airports over the summer, and some passengers missed flights as border delays were blamed on the new technology and staffing constraints.
Current status of the EES and legal case
Eu-LISA has stated that the legal proceedings have no impact on the functioning of the Entry/Exit System, which it says is fully operational across Europe. The European Commission has indicated that it is not a party to the case and that the dispute concerns delays in the delivery of the system during development, rather than its current operation.
A spokesperson for Estonia’s Harju County Court confirmed that the civil case has been filed there, and no hearings have yet taken place or been scheduled. IBM, Atos, Leonardo and eu-LISA did not immediately respond to requests for comment outside regular business hours, while the agency has previously said it found no security breaches linked to the project.
Key Takeaways
- 01The EU’s lawsuit centers on contractual delays and penalties tied to the Entry/Exit System’s development, not its present-day use at the border.
- 02Despite significant rollout issues, eu-LISA maintains that the EES is now fully operational across the Schengen area.
- 03There were long-running tensions between the agency and the IBM–Atos–Leonardo consortium over fines, deadlines and project responsibility.
References
- https://finance.yahoo.com/technology/articles/market-chatter-ibm-among-companies-150214857.html?.tsrc=rss
- https://www.theguardian.com/world/2026/nov/09/eu-lawsuit-ibm-atos-leonardo-entry-exit-border-system
- https://thenextweb.com/news/eu-sues-ibm-atos-leonardo-entry-exit-system
- https://www.thestar.com.my/tech/tech-news/2026/11/09/eu-sues-ibm-and-two-european-companies-over-troubled-border-system-ft-reports