
Key Points
- 01Mondelez (MDLZ) files UK High Court action over Catherine’s O’bar shape
- 02Owner of Toblerone alleges trademark and design infringement
- 03Catherine’s Originals rejects claims and plans to defend case
- 04Legal experts say proving shape-based infringement may be difficult
Mondelez launches UK lawsuit over O’bar design
Mondelez International (MDLZ) has begun legal action in the UK against independent vegan chocolate maker Catherine’s Originals, alleging that the design of its O’bar infringes the protected shape and trademarks of Toblerone. Kraft Foods Schweiz Holding GmbH, part of the Mondelez group, has filed a claim at the High Court in London that centres on trademark and physical design issues linked to the iconic Toblerone bar. Mondelez argues that Catherine’s O’bar product range, including a 200g bar, seeks to pass off a design similar to Toblerone’s triangle-based confectionery line and takes unfair advantage of the brand’s reputation.
The Toblerone shape has been protected as a trademark in the UK since 1994 and is described by Mondelez as one of the most recognised and distinctive product designs in the UK and worldwide, serving as a hallmark of the brand since 1929. The company states that it has a responsibility to protect its trademarks and intellectual property and that it tried for several months to resolve the matter directly with Catherine’s Originals before proceeding with litigation.
Claims and counterclaims over chocolate bar shape
Mondelez contends that the chunky O’bar’s design risks confusing consumers by echoing Toblerone’s trade marked shape. The corporation claims the O’bar’s segments unfairly draw on Toblerone’s established reputation, even though the vegan bar features rounded, semi-oval segments rather than sharp alpine-style peaks. Catherine’s Originals’ O’bar is a slender rectangle of chocolate with 10 protruding rounded blocks.
Catherine’s Originals strongly disputes the allegations and maintains that the O’bar has its own distinctive identity. Founder Catherine Dodd, who set up the West Sussex-based vegan business in 2021, writes that the curved, rounded segments are intended to represent the “O” in Originals and that the colourful stripes, flavours and packaging stories reflect her personal design vision. She emphasises that the business is independent with no commercial affiliation to Toblerone or Mondelez and insists that O’bar does not infringe the trademark rights asserted against it.
Start-up response and funding its legal defence
Dodd describes the legal action as frightening and says the experience has felt like being “bullied into submission”, while confirming that she will vigorously defend Catherine’s Originals alongside her legal team. Legal advisor Stephen Lowry states that the company considers O’bar to have its own distinctive design and looks forward to resolving the matter through the appropriate legal process. Dodd notes that there has been a strong response from customers, including many who had not previously heard of the brand but have expressed support.
In response to offers of crowdfunding, Catherine’s Originals has instead launched a “Battle Bundle” on its website, allocating 15% of sales from those items towards covering legal costs. Dodd says this mechanism will help finance the challenge to the claim as the High Court case proceeds. The dispute highlights the resource gap between the multinational confectionery group, which reports annual revenues exceeding $38 billion, and the small, family-run vegan start-up.
Legal context and challenges of shape trademarks
Intellectual property specialists observe that cases focused on product shape remain relatively rare and can be complex. Commentators note that shape trademarks are often interpreted narrowly, and the court will need to assess how similar the products actually appear. One view is that proving that Catherine’s O’bar is sufficiently similar to cause consumer confusion could be challenging, even with an existing registration protecting Toblerone’s shape.
Experts add that Toblerone’s high level of reputation may still play a role, because infringement can be found if another product’s shape is sufficiently similar to evoke a link with the famous mark in the mind of the average consumer, even without direct confusion. At the same time, it is acknowledged that a drawn-out court process may be daunting for a much smaller manufacturer, and that any final outcome could hinge on how closely judges deem the competing designs to align.
Key Takeaways
- 01The case centres on whether Catherine’s O’bar is sufficiently similar to Toblerone’s long-protected shape to infringe trademark rights.
- 02Mondelez (MDLZ) seeks to enforce design and trademark protections, while Catherine’s Originals presents the O’bar as an independent, distinctive concept.
- 03Legal experts highlight that shape-based claims are difficult to prove and will require close judicial scrutiny of consumer perception and product similarity.
References
- https://www.just-food.com/news/mondelez-enters-trademark-battle-with-uk-start-up-catherines-originals/?.tsrc=rss
- https://www.veganfoodandliving.com/news/mondelez-toblerone-sues-catherines-originals-obar/
- https://www.foodmanufacture.co.uk/Article/2026/11/02/vegan-chocolate-maker-catherines-originals-faces-legal-threat-from-mondelez-over-obar-shape/
- https://www.confectioneryproduction.com/news/60117/mondelez-issues-legal-action-against-catherines-originals-uk-chocolate-firm/